Professor of Law Emeritus William Banks provided Newsweek with background on Martial Law in the wake of South Korea’s President Yoon Suk Yeol declaring “emergency martial law” on December 3.
“Historically, martial law has been invoked when the national government is unable to enforce the laws in society. In effect martial law places the nation’s military in charge, and the rules that might be put in place are subject only to the commanders’ discretion,” says Banks. “Martial law has only rarely been invoked in the United States, as it is viewed as an extreme measure for the most turbulent times. In the 18th century English legal scholar Blackstone wrote that martial law is in “reality no law, but something indulge rather than allowed as law.”
In reviewing the state’s report on the facility, Kohn commented “We really need to be thinking about penalties beyond inspections. Is this a facility that the state should be licensing?”
Several Syracuse Law students from the International Law Society (ILS) recently attended the International Law Weekend Conference (ILW), hosted by the American Branch of the International Law Association (ABILA). The students were accompanied by Professor Cora True-Frost G’01, L’01, Faculty Advisor to the ILS, the most recent cohort in a longstanding tradition of Syracuse Law students attending the ILW.
At the conference, students participated in panels addressing some of the most pressing legal challenges facing the world today, including space law, immigration law, and labor regulation enforcement. They also had the chance to network with leading experts in international law, gaining valuable insights and perspectives on the global legal landscape.
“The conference gave students the opportunity to think through the legal problems they will address in their careers, both immediately after graduating and throughout their lifetimes, while also networking with attorneys from around the world and exploring job opportunities in various fields of international law,” says Zoe Tkaczyk L’25, president of the ILS. “The weekend in New York gave us the opportunity to get to know our classmates better and to spend time together and with alumni.”
Omar Sabbatini, an exchange student from the University of Rome Tor Vergata in Italy, who is spending the fall 2024 semester at Syracuse Law, highlighted the significance of the conference. “The ABILA’s ILW allowed us to engage with prominent figures in international law, including individuals who might seem distant from us—such as the author of our international law textbook, who participated in a panel alongside the Swiss and Chinese ambassadors,” he said. “Our attendance enabled us to establish meaningful connections with students and professionals while delving into lesser-known areas of international law, such as the law of people at sea. It also illuminated pressing issues, such as the situation of women in Afghanistan, through direct and authentic testimonies.”
“The International Law Weekend Conference provided Syracuse Law students with a unique platform to expand their global perspectives, deepen their understanding of international law, and connect with a diverse community of legal scholars and practitioners,” says True-Frost.
Crandall Melvin Professor of Law Shubha Ghosh, director of the Syracuse Intellectual Property Law Institute, recently spoke with The Verge for their article “Breaking down the DOJ’s plan to end Google’s search monopoly.” The DOJ has proposed many remedies after a federal judge ruled that Google monopolized internet search and other services.
Discussing the possibility of Google selling its Chrome browser, Ghosh says “There is definitely an issue about whether you’re just simply transferring a valuable asset from one company where these assets are too tightly integrated, to another company.”
Another proposed remedy is for Google to license some of its most valuable data. “Data is not really protected, per se, by intellectual property,” Ghosh says. “It’s not like Google created the data. They created the platform that allowed the data to be generated.” It’s like asking who owns a news event, he adds. “The news is just what happens, and you just have an agency that collects it or observes it. But that doesn’t by itself create any kind of property right.”
Many students at the Syracuse University College of Law aim to work as general counsel at some point in their careers. And, while most have a sense of what that job title entails, Syracuse University College of Law students who participated in the General Counsel Symposium, sponsored by the Corporate Law Society (CLS) in Dineen Hall, had a unique opportunity to network and gain face-to-face insights from prestigious alumni and guests willing to share their own experiences working as general counsel for leading corporations around the globe.
“Every single alumnus I reached out to said ‘yes’—a true testament to the Orange alumni network.”
—Brett VanBuren L’25
The concept started last February when Brett VanBuren L’25, president of the CLS, proposed the idea of organizing a General Counsel Symposium to Lily Yan Hughes, assistant dean of career services and student experiences. After getting the green light, VanBuren and his team of Nicholas Troia L’25, Gabriella Amaturo L’25 and Dana Krinsky L’25, as well as Director of Alumni Relations Adrienne Lutz, started to assemble a diverse lineup of alumni and a few others with outstanding experience working as general counsel.
“Every single alumnus I reached out to said ‘yes’—a true testament to the Orange alumni network” said VanBuren.
Alumni Paired With Student Organizations on Current Issues Link
Early in the day, alumni and other guests were paired with various Syracuse Law student organizations based on areas of interest and expertise.
Students from the Bankruptcy Clinic had the opportunity to meet with Melanie Gray L’81, former chair, Syracuse University College of Law Advisory Board and Syracuse University trustee, who practiced complex commercial law and was lead attorney on behalf of Enron during its Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing, which, at the time, was the largest corporate bankruptcy in U.S. history.
Leslie Park L’95, assistant general counsel and senior vice president, legal & business affairs, Hallmark Media, explained some of the challenges faced by her company, primarily due to its extensive movie library, to the Entertainment and Sports Law Society (ESLS). “Leslie Park provided such an eye-opening perspective on the different ways in which the law intersects with the entertainment industry,” said Krinsky, president of the ESLS. “She shared candid advice about how to break into the industry and truly took the time to listen to members’ goals and respond with tailored recommendations.
A former lead articles editor of Syracuse Law Review, Aaron Tidman L’07 met with current editors outlining his non-traditional career path that eventually led him to his current work as assistant general counsel and director of compliance at Pinterest.
Rebecca Peters ’00 MPA (MAX), L’00, director of public policy, semiconductor policy, Samsung, met with the Women’s Law Student Association for a conversation about her own career path, along with changes being made in the legal profession today.
Jim Dixon, retired senior vice president and chief legal officer, RWE Clean Energy, met with students from the Veterans Law Society and the Environmental Law Society. “We were allotted about 30 minutes, but Jim conversed with us for over an hour-and-a-half,” said Luke Overdyk ’22 (Falk), L’26. “Much of our career pursuit is internet based, and it can be difficult to navigate. It was encouraging to hear from a professional like Jim in person and speak candidly. He welcomed our many questions and offered his best advice for aspiring environmental lawyers.”
Panel Discussions Gave Students Practical Insight From Prestigious Thought Leaders Link
In the afternoon, Syracuse Law Dean Terence J. Lau L’98 welcomed attendees to the Melanie Gray Ceremonial Courtroom.
“This symposium is an outstanding example of the bonds that Syracuse Law forges between students, alumni and industry partners through mentorships that span generations and philanthropy that opens doors for the next wave of legal minds,” said Lau. “To our students here today—look around. These accomplished professionals were once where you are now. And, they’re here today because they believe in you and your potential to change the world.”
Following the dean’s remarks, four discussion sessions were offered to students, including Syracuse Law’s JDinteractive (JDi) students, who were able to participate through a livestream. Each session was comprised of a panel of several alumni or other guests with specific expertise as general counsel. These sessions included:
Left to right: Jim Dixon, Prashanth “PJ” Jayachandran ’98 MPA, L’98, and Mary Snyder L’02
Welcome to In-House: The Role of General Counsel with panelists Dixon, Mary Snyder L’02, executive vice president & general counsel, SRC; and Prashanth “PJ” Jayachandran ’98 MPA, L’98, senior vice president & chief supply chain counsel, Colgate-Palmolive, and a distinguished lecturer at Syracuse Law. This session helped clearly define what a general counsel does, as well as understand how a solid knowledge of business can influence senior leadership by offering new ideas or measures that mitigate risk.
Left to right: Kris Kiefer L’05, Leslie Park L’95, and Aaron Tidman L’07
Getting to the Boardroom: The Path to In-House Success with panelists Park, Tidman and Kris Kiefer L’05, assistant general counsel and director, National Grid. Many students attending this session were interested in hearing about what companies are looking for when hiring a general counsel, as well as the importance of developing excellent soft skills, like listening, communicating and wanting to do the right thing.
Legal Competency in Tech: Let’s Talk Semiconductors with panelists Peters and Richard Thurston, current chairman, CEO and chief legal officer, Hudson Valley Fast Fab; founder of RLT Global, a semiconductor consulting firm, and retired senior vice president, general counsel, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., was particularly valuable, as the Syracuse community prepares for Micron Technologies to build a $100 billion chip manufacturing facility in Central New York.
Left to right: Brett VanBuren L’25, Melanie Gray L’81, and Lily Hughes.
Leadership Challenges: Handling the Best and the Worst Days of a Company with panelists Gray and Hughes, who, before joining Syracuse Law, was a former chief legal officer at Arrow Electronics and vice president and associate, general counsel for corporate finance and mergers and acquisitions at Ingram Micro, a former Fortune 100 New York Stock Exchange-listed company. Students heard how every successful career comes with some mistakes along the way and were encouraged to “own up to it and disclose it,” by Hughes, who said most problems have solutions if they are identified quickly.
Evening Session Focused on Negotiations, Competition Link
After a reception where students were able to further engage with participating alumni and guests, Jeff Gewirtz, executive vice president, business affairs chief legal officer, Brooklyn Sports and Entertainment Global, Zoomed in from New York City to speak to the group on negotiations, as well as how his law degree has set him up for success in the business world.
Bringing the day to a close was the final round of the inaugural Corporate Law Society’s Business Negotiation Competition (BNC), sponsored by local firm Bousquet Holstein. Two teams of law students who made it through to this final round negotiated a real world business scenario in front of judges that included Gray, Park and Thurston.
Sixteen competitors in teams of two participated in the BNC, which is a hallmark of Syracuse Law’s intercollegiate advocacy competitions. Through three preliminary rounds held earlier in the month, students worked on fictitious legal scenarios until two teams made it to the finals. Austin Dewey L’26 and Gregory Patrick L’26 went head-to-head against Krinsky and James Cameron III L’25 in a scenario involving negotiating a new terminal, additional routes and a percentage of local hires for an airline establishing a new hub. In the end, the team of Cameron and Krinsky walked away with the win.
Overall, the first General Counsel Symposium was a great accomplishment, according to VanBuren. “I think it was a success thanks to the openness of our alumni who were willing to share their own stories,” he said. “I knew every one of them was going to be a hit, as each person not only has already had an accomplished career but was honest, passionate and humorous. I think the outcome of the day was witnessing how wide-ranging the work of a general counsel can be. There was something for everyone—from employment law to legal ethics to emerging technology. I hope the General Council Symposium continues to happen every year and only grows in impact.”
Crandall Melvin Professor of Law Shubha Ghosh recently spoke with the Associated Press on the DOJ’s request that a federal judge impose several sanctions to break up Google’s monopoly on search engines and other technologies. The request includes the potential sale of the Chrome web browser and that its Android operating system should be completely walled off from the company’s search engine.
“It is probably going a little beyond,” Ghosh said of the Chrome breakup. “The remedies should match the harm; it should match the transgression. This does seem a little beyond that pale.”
Austin Dewey L’26 and Madison Mahar L’26 prevailed over William Baldwin L’27 and Brady Sterpe L’27 in Syracuse Law’s First Annual Entertainment Negotiation Competition (ENC), hosted by the Entertainment and Sports Law Society (ESLS).
The final round was judged by Veronica Ramirez L’18 Owner and Lead Attorney at Curator Counsel; Barry Slotnick L’72, Chair of Intellectual Property and Entertainment Litigation at Loeb & Loeb; and Payton Sorci L’22, Legal Assistant at Endeavor.
The ENC covered various entertainment law topics, including Intellectual Property, Contracts, and Finance. Teams negotiated terms for a fictional series of fact patterns centered on Justin Bieber: a record deal between Bieber and Universal Records; a brand endorsement deal between Bieber and Balenciaga; a movie deal between Bieber and Marvel Studios; and for the final round, a Vegas residency deal between Bieber and Caesars Palace.
The ESLS will host its 5th Annual Sports Negotiation Competition in Spring, 2025.
Professor Emeritus William Banks recently spoke with the Boston Globe for the story “Could Donald Trump really deport undocumented immigrants who live in Mass.?”
Banks points to Trump using the Insurrection Act to federalize the National Guard. The president does not need a governor’s approval to invoke the act, Banks said, though lawsuits against the move would be likely.
If Trump were to successfully federalize the National Guard, he would not only have authority over the Massachusetts National Guard, but he would also be able to send National Guard troops from other states here.
“That would be pretty extreme — but it’s not implausible,” Banks said. “The Insurrection Act has such an open texture to it, that presidents can run with it.”
Alexa Connaughton L’25 and Elyse Maniccia L’26 recently competed in the National Veterans Law Moot Court Competition (NVLMCC), the nation’s most prestigious veterans law appellate competition. Seth Owens L’24, Betty and Miachel D. Wohl Veterans Legal Clinic Staff Attorney, coached the team and was assisted by Army JAG Major Nick VanErp.
The students were judged 1/3 on the content of their brief, 1/3 on their first argument, and 1/3 on their second argument. While the Syracuse Law team did not advance past the initial round, they proudly represented the College of Law. They had a positive experience learning the unique complexities of veterans law.
“I am very proud of their effort; both students were great ambassadors for Syracuse Law. One may even be interested in changing their preferred career path to pursue veterans law after this experience,” says Owens. “I would also like to note that we were the only team eliminated on day one to attend all rounds of the final arguments. The students enjoyed watching the competitors and used it as an opportunity to further their advocacy skills and self-reflect.”
First organized in 2009, NVLMCC is sponsored annually by the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC), the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims Bar Association, and the George Washington University Law School (GW Law). The NVLMCC is the nation’s premier moot court focusing on veterans law. Hosted close to Veterans Day each fall in Washington, DC, the NVLMCC brings together 28 teams of two students from around the country to argue cutting-edge veterans law issues before panels of distinguished practitioners and judges.
The NVLMCC prides itself on the authenticity of the problems and the quality of its judges. The record on appeal and the documents included look like what would be found in a real veterans law case. The judges for the briefs and the oral arguments are drawn from the ranks of experienced veterans law practitioners. In particular, the final round of each NVLMCC is presided over by a panel of judges from the CAVC in their courtroom. Few moot court competitions can boast an experience that is so true to actual practice.
George Saad L’25 won the Best Cross-Examination award at the Buffalo-Niagara Trial Competition. His cross-examination was deemed the best out of 96 cross-examinations during the preliminary rounds. The Syracuse Law team of Tania Rivera-Bullard, Dannah Henderson, Lisa Musto, Saad, Kaylee Searcy, and Taylor Shawver finished in 5th place out of 24 teams.
